Based on the true story of Hanyost Schuyler, whose role in saving the lives of hundreds of Americans besieged at Fort Stanwix in 1777 has long been forgotten.

Neither Rebel Nor Tory tells the forgotten story of Hanyost Schuyler who was reviled in his own time as a fool and a traitor. Growing up in the multiracial world of the Mohawk Valley just before the American Revolution, Hanyost was drawn to the ancient ways of the Mohawks and rejected the culture of his own people. Although his uncle Nicholas Herkimer was the richest white man in the valley, Hanyost chose as his mentor Black Jacob, the son of a fugitive slave.When war broke out in 1776, Hanyost wanted only to be left alone. Caught between both sides, and in love with a Mohawk girl, he was condemned to hang as a traitor. Escaping this fate through the power of his imagination, Hanyost persuaded a large invading force of British, Tories and Iroquois warriors to break off the critical siege of Fort Stanwix and flee back to Canada.

In July of 1776, the American colonies are ablaze with passion as the people of the new nation choose between their king and an uncertain future. Kate Darby, a once timid Quaker joins her brother as a spy for the patriots.