Institutional Change in Judicial Selection Systems
Title | Institutional Change in Judicial Selection Systems PDF eBook |
Author | |
Publisher | |
Pages | 266 |
Release | 2014 |
Genre | |
ISBN |
Judicial Selection in the States
Title | Judicial Selection in the States PDF eBook |
Author | Herbert M. Kritzer |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Pages | 401 |
Release | 2020-04-30 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1108496334 |
How do legal professionalism and politics influence efforts to structure the process of selecting and retaining state judges?
Judicial Merit Selection
Title | Judicial Merit Selection PDF eBook |
Author | Greg Goelzhauser |
Publisher | Temple University Press |
Pages | 0 |
Release | 2019-02-22 |
Genre | Political Science |
ISBN | 9781439918074 |
The judicial selection debate continues. Merit selection is used by a majority of states but remains the least well understood method for choosing judges. Proponents claim that it emphasizes qualifications and diversity over politics, but there is little empirical evidence regarding its performance. In Judicial Merit Selection, Greg Goelzhauser amasses a wealth of data to examine merit selection’s institutional performance from an internal perspective. While his previous book, Choosing State Supreme Court Justices, compares outcomes across selection mechanisms, here he delves into what makes merit selection unique—its use of nominating commissions to winnow applicants prior to gubernatorial appointment. Goelzhauser’s analyses include a rich case study from inside a nominating commission’s proceedings as it works to choose nominees; the use of public records to examine which applicants commissions choose and which nominees governors choose; evaluation of which attorneys apply for consideration and which judges apply for promotion; and examination of whether design differences across systems impact performance in the seating of qualified and diverse judges. The results have critical public policy implications.
Making Law and Courts Research Relevant
Title | Making Law and Courts Research Relevant PDF eBook |
Author | Brandon L. Bartels |
Publisher | Routledge |
Pages | 281 |
Release | 2014-09-04 |
Genre | Political Science |
ISBN | 1317693450 |
One of the more enduring topics of concern for empirically-oriented scholars of law and courts—and political scientists more generally—is how research can be more directly relevant to broader audiences outside of academia. A significant part of this issue goes back to a seeming disconnect between empirical and normative scholars of law and courts that has increased in recent years. Brandon L. Bartels and Chris W. Bonneau argue that being attuned to the normative implications of one’s work enhances the quality of empirical work, not to mention makes it substantially more interesting to both academics and non-academic practitioners. Their book’s mission is to examine how the normative implications of empirical work in law and courts can be more visible and relevant to audiences beyond academia. Written by scholars of political science, law, and sociology, the chapters in the volume offer ideas on a methodology for communicating normative implications in a balanced, nuanced, and modest manner. The contributors argue that if empirical work is strongly suggestive of certain policy or institutional changes, scholars should make those implications known so that information can be diffused. The volume consists of four sections that respectively address the general enterprise of developing normative implications of empirical research, law and decisionmaking, judicial selection, and courts in the broader political and societal context. This volume represents the start of a conversation on the topic of how the normative implications of empirical research in law and courts can be made more visible. This book will primarily interest scholars of law and courts, as well as students of judicial politics. Other subfields of political science engaging in empirical research will also find the suggestions made in the book relevant.
Research on Judicial Selection, 1999
Title | Research on Judicial Selection, 1999 PDF eBook |
Author | American Judicature Society |
Publisher | |
Pages | 120 |
Release | 2000-02 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 9781928919001 |
Judicial Selection in the States
Title | Judicial Selection in the States PDF eBook |
Author | Herbert M. Kritzer |
Publisher | Cambridge University Press |
Pages | 401 |
Release | 2020-04-30 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1108853684 |
Using detailed case studies of the relevant US states, Herbert Kritzer provides an unprecedented examination of the process and politics of how states select and retain judges. The book is organized around the competing goals of politics and professionalism, namely whether the focus in choosing judges should be on future judicial decisions (court outputs) or on the court processes by which those decisions are reached. Or, in considering who should be a judge, whether the emphasis should be on political credentials or on professional credentials. One important finding is that political concerns have surpassed professionalism concerns since 2000. Another is that voters have been more supportive of professionalism in selecting appellate judges than trial judges. Judicial Selection in the States should be read by anyone seeking a deep understanding of the complex interplay between politics and the judiciary at the state level in the United States.
Literature on Judicial Selection
Title | Literature on Judicial Selection PDF eBook |
Author | Nancy Chinn |
Publisher | |
Pages | 122 |
Release | 1980 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN |