One of the long-standing maxims of equity is that “he who comes into equity must come with clean hands.” It is closely related to the maxim that “he who seeks equity must do equity.” These equitable principles are “an historical reflection of the fact that courts of equity began as courts of conscience.” In this country and throughout the common law world, unclean hands has tradition- ally been a defense to equitable claims, but not to legal claims.Yet in the case below the Federal Circuit applied the equitable defense of unclean hands to a legal claim for damages for patent infringement. The Federal Circuit repeatedly relied on precedents of this Court that characterize unclean hands as an equitable defense that constrains a court of equity. The Federal Circuit provided no support whatsoever for applying the equitable defense of unclean hands to a legal claim for damages, especially when that equitable defense would displace the verdict of a jury.

Modern American Remedies: Cases and Materials Concise Fifth Edition

The fusion of law and equity in common law systems was a crucial moment in the development of the modern law. In this volume leading scholars assess the significance of the fusion of law and equity from comparative, doctrinal, historical and theoretical perspectives.

ADMINISTRATIVE RECORDS FOR SURVEY METHODOLOGY Addresses the international use of administrative records for large-scale surveys, censuses, and other statistical purposes Administrative Records for Survey Methodology is a comprehensive guide to improving the quality, cost-efficiency, and interpretability of surveys and censuses using administrative data research. Contributions from a team of internationally-recognized experts provide practical approaches for integrating administrative data in statistical surveys, and discuss the methodological issues—including concerns of privacy, confidentiality, and legality—involved in collecting and analyzing administrative records. Numerous real-world examples highlight technological and statistical innovations, helping readers gain a better understanding of both fundamental methods and advanced techniques for controlling data quality reducing total survey error. Divided into four sections, the first describes the basics of administrative records research and addresses disclosure limitation and confidentiality protection in linked data. Section two focuses on data quality and linking methodology, covering topics such as quality evaluation, measuring and controlling for non-consent bias, and cleaning and using administrative lists. The third section examines the use of administrative records in surveys and includes case studies of the Swedish register-based census and the administrative records applications used for the US 2020 Census. The book’s final section discusses combining administrative and survey data to improve income measurement, enhancing health surveys with data linkage, and other uses of administrative data in evidence-based policymaking. This state-of-the-art resource: Discusses important administrative data issues and suggests how administrative data can be integrated with more traditional surveys Describes practical uses of administrative records for evidence-driven decisions in both public and private sectors Emphasizes using interdisciplinary methodology and linking administrative records with other data sources Explores techniques to leverage administrative data to improve the survey frame, reduce nonresponse follow-up, assess coverage error, measure linkage non-consent bias, and perform small area estimation. Administrative Records for Survey Methodology is an indispensable reference and guide for statistical researchers and methodologists in academia, industry, and government, particularly census bureaus and national statistical offices, and an ideal supplemental text for undergraduate and graduate courses in data science, survey methodology, data collection, and data analysis methods.

Weaver, Shoben and Kelly's Principles of Remedies Law discusses its subject in a student-friendly style. It is designed to facilitate learning and comprehension.