An Empirical Inquiry Into the Relation of Corrective Justice to Distributive Justice
Title | An Empirical Inquiry Into the Relation of Corrective Justice to Distributive Justice PDF eBook |
Author | Gregory Mitchell |
Publisher | |
Pages | 0 |
Release | 2011 |
Genre | |
ISBN |
We report the results of three experiments examining the long-standing debate within tort theory over whether corrective justice is independent of, or parasitic on, distributive justice. Using a "hypothetical societies" paradigm that serves as an impartial reasoning device and permits experimental manipulation of societal conditions, we first tested support for corrective justice in a society where individual merit played no role in determining economic standing. Participants expressed strong support for a norm of corrective justice in response to intentional and unintentional torts in both just and unjust societies. The second experiment tested support for corrective justice in a society where race, rather than individual merit, determined economic standing. The distributive justice manipulation exerted greater effect here, particularly on liberal participants, but support for corrective justice remained strong among non-liberal participants, even against a background of racially unjust distributive conditions. The third experiment partially replicated the first experiment and found that the availability of government-funded insurance had little effect on demands for corrective justice. Overall, the results suggest that, while extreme distributive injustice can moderate support for corrective justice, the norm of corrective justice often dominates judgments about compensatory duties associated with tortious harms.
Distributive and Procedural Justice
Title | Distributive and Procedural Justice PDF eBook |
Author | Kjell Törnblom |
Publisher | Routledge |
Pages | 340 |
Release | 2016-05-23 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1317149343 |
This interdisciplinary and cross-national volume brings together theory and research by prominent scholars within the areas of distributive and procedural justice, not only featuring work within each area separately, as is commonly done, but also showing how combinations of the two justice orientations might operate to affect justice judgments and guide behaviour. Chapters cover various levels of analysis, from intra-personal to interpersonal to group and societal levels. The volume is divided into four sections: distributive justice, procedural justice, distributive and procedural justice, and methodological issues. Each section is subdivided into two parts, basic research and applied research re: current and important societal issues. Each chapter contains an overview of theoretical and empirical research on a particular topic. The volume is designed for use on courses in social psychology, psychology, sociology, political philosophy, and law.
Corrective and Distributive Justice
Title | Corrective and Distributive Justice PDF eBook |
Author | Izhak Englard |
Publisher | Oxford University Press |
Pages | 256 |
Release | 2009-02-17 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0199748438 |
Corrective and Distributive Justice: From Aristotle to Modern Times retraces the intricate history of the distinction between corrective and distributive justice. This distinction is elaborated in the 5th book of Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, which was rediscovered in Western Europe in the 12th and 13th centuries by the Scholastics and turned into a central topic in legal and theological scholarship. After a decline of interest in the wake of the enlightenment and secularization, a surprising revival of these notions of justice occurred in U.S. legal and philosophical discourse during the last four decades that has made this distinction a central issue in tort law, restitution and other important fields of private and public law. In literally hundreds of articles and a considerable number of books, the Aristotelian distinction has been elaborated, discussed, and applied. Englard's unique contribution to this aspect of legal history grants the contemporary reader a historical perspective that is vital for a deepened understanding of the distinction and modern concerns. Organized chronologically, Englard's research covers: Aristotle, High Scholastics, Late Scholastics, Post-Scholastics, and Modernity. The relevant literature is notoriously difficult to access, not only because of its Latin language, but because of the physical rarity of the relevant books scattered throughout the world. This book offers the modern reader a touchstone synthesis of intellectual and legal history.
How Much Do We Deserve?
Title | How Much Do We Deserve? PDF eBook |
Author | Richard S. Gilbert |
Publisher | Unitarian Universalist Association of Congregations |
Pages | 236 |
Release | 2001 |
Genre | Business & Economics |
ISBN | 9781558964167 |
Sheds new light on the injustice arising from the widening gap between rich and poor in the United States.
Yale Law Journal: Volume 121, Number 1 - October 2011
Title | Yale Law Journal: Volume 121, Number 1 - October 2011 PDF eBook |
Author | Yale Law Journal |
Publisher | Quid Pro Books |
Pages | 495 |
Release | 2011-10-20 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1610279638 |
One of the world's leading law journals is now available in quality ebook formats. This issue of The Yale Law Journal (the first issue of Volume 121, academic year 2011-2012) features new articles and essays on jurisprudence, tort law, and other areas of interest. Contributors include such noted scholars as Jules Coleman, Ariel Porat, and Mark Geistfeld. The issue also features student contributions on counter-terrorism and on felon disenfranchisement. Digital formatting includes linked notes and an active Table of Contents (including linked Tables of Contents for individual articles and essays), as well as linked cross-references and properly presented tables.
Research Handbook on Private Law Theory
Title | Research Handbook on Private Law Theory PDF eBook |
Author | Hanoch Dagan |
Publisher | Edward Elgar Publishing |
Pages | 520 |
Release | 2020-12-25 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 1788971620 |
This comprehensive Research Handbook provides an unparalleled overview of contemporary private law theory. Featuring original contributions by leading experts in the field, its extensive examinations of the core areas of contracts, property and torts are complemented by an exploration of a breadth of topics that cross the divide between private and public law, including labor law and corporate law.
How Judges Think
Title | How Judges Think PDF eBook |
Author | Richard A. Posner |
Publisher | Harvard University Press |
Pages | 399 |
Release | 2010-05-01 |
Genre | Law |
ISBN | 0674033833 |
A distinguished and experienced appellate court judge, Richard A. Posner offers in this new book a unique and, to orthodox legal thinkers, a startling perspective on how judges and justices decide cases. When conventional legal materials enable judges to ascertain the true facts of a case and apply clear pre-existing legal rules to them, Posner argues, they do so straightforwardly; that is the domain of legalist reasoning. However, in non-routine cases, the conventional materials run out and judges are on their own, navigating uncharted seas with equipment consisting of experience, emotions, and often unconscious beliefs. In doing so, they take on a legislative role, though one that is confined by internal and external constraints, such as professional ethics, opinions of respected colleagues, and limitations imposed by other branches of government on freewheeling judicial discretion. Occasional legislators, judges are motivated by political considerations in a broad and sometimes a narrow sense of that term. In that open area, most American judges are legal pragmatists. Legal pragmatism is forward-looking and policy-based. It focuses on the consequences of a decision in both the short and the long term, rather than on its antecedent logic. Legal pragmatism so understood is really just a form of ordinary practical reasoning, rather than some special kind of legal reasoning. Supreme Court justices are uniquely free from the constraints on ordinary judges and uniquely tempted to engage in legislative forms of adjudication. More than any other court, the Supreme Court is best understood as a political court.